Talk:Rubedo/@comment-2A02:A442:4DB:1:FDE1:7E86:93BA:9312-20170803110201/@comment-26144500-20170812003455

Well.. I overreacted... (I got triggered from the theory-speculation thing, disregarding any theorizing about the future events)

So, now that I've calmed down, I still have something to say.

Sidali891, you said " Saying that The Goal of All Life is Death wouldn't work on Rubedo is the same as saying any special skill wouldn't work on an NPC made of a WCI."

This shows that you didn't read my comment correctly(or I wasn't clear enough, but I think I was).

1- When I spoke/wrote of TGoALID not affecting Rubedo, I meant it indirectly. After all, like I mentioned before, TGoALID is a boost to instant death spells, not an effect casted on an enemy. As such, the thing would target Rubedo would be the TGoALID boosted instant death spell.

2- No, I don't think(and I don't remember saying) that any special skill wouldn't work on an NPC made of a WCI. I said that a special skill or spell that goes against the effect of a WCI wouldn't work(which a fact). There's a difference. A special skill that doesn't go against the effect of the Caloric Stone would theorically work.

3-  Thus, my speculation was centered around 2 things, that A-the Caloric Stone had making Rubedo alive among its effects and B- that the " TGoALID boosted instant death spell" would be counted as going against the previously mentioned effect of the Caloric Stone and thus wouldn't work. THIS was my speculation. (Points 1 and 2 are Facts, while this point 3 is a speculation.)

(And since I'm quite bad at summarizing, the first time I tried to put it in words it ended up in a way too long comment, which also apparently wasn't clear enough since it cause you to misunderstand my points. I hope this more summarized version to be easier to understand, no matter whether you agree or not.)