Talk:Bellriver/@comment-218.215.15.250-20190413155516/@comment-37782702-20190418225447

To Obaru

The only weakness of Wish Upon a star is that it can't counter the EFFECTS of World items. That's its only limitation.

This means that a caster can use it to grant a wish That brings all World Class items to them. Since World class items arent EFFECTS, they can do this. This counters your "Wish upon a star can't affect WORLD related" argument

Heres a quote from the novel

"Once the ripples of emotion faded away, Ainz realised that 「Wish Upon A Star」 worked differently here than it did in YGGDRASIL.

When Ainz had first learned of Nfirea’s talent, he had idly wondered if he could steal it with 「Wish Upon A Star」. Now, he realized that he could have done it. In this world, 「Wish Upon a Star」 was a spell that would grant its caster’s wishes. Although it would still expend XP, 「Wish Upon A Star」 was now a spell that could make the impossible possible. In addition, by sacrificing five levels — five hundred percent of his XP bar — one could one could make even greater wishes come true." Volume 3 Chapter 3

With this in mind, Ainz should use the "Shooting star ring" to either Extremely lower the xp requirement, or Make all wishes no matter how matter how strong the wish is, cost nothing. Smart idea right? this counters your "Massive EXP requirement"  Also you overlooked my "Have the spell cost No Exp to use" idea.

I don't understand why your trying to downplay {Wish Upon A Star} and the ring. It's one of the strongest items from YGGDRASSIL and thats undeniably a fact. It can do all the wishes i mentioned above. It has no other limitations until The author says so.