Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-33022048-20171019153725/@comment-27309048-20171019163418

My guess is that should be Prince Brabo. Unfortunately he attacked Carne Village and died.

The 4  people Ainz wanted to spare:

- Climb: There are no questions about Climb being one of the four people. By the events of vol. 6, 9, 10 we can assume that there is an agreement going on between Nazarick and Renner, and that the agreement ensures Climb safety.

- The King: The King is Renner's father, and in a sense the head of the Kingdom. If the King perished the Kingdom would be swept by chaos. Not only the cede of E-Rantel territory to the Sorcerer Kingdom not happen, the nobles would be fighting for power and Renner would become one of the chips.

-Gazef: Ainz wanted Gazef to join his camp. Ainz admires Gazef because Gazef has a resolve that Ainz don't have. This has some relation with Ainz collector spirit, he likes to collect new things even if they are weak in relations of himself. You can see this when Ainz get holds of new itens, or when he tries to get new subordinates. (Hajimal, Go gin are some exemples)

-Prince Brabo: This is something i'm not so sure about. When they are planning the war in vol. 9 Prince Brabro volunteer himself to go to battle. The thing is, there is not a timeline of when the battle in Carne Village happened, and when the battle in the Kaize Plains happened. Ainz could not known that the prince wasn't in the Kingdom's army, and was attacking Carne. We discovered in vol. 10 that Nazarick has taken control of the Kingdom underworld, and is mentioned in vol.6 that Prince Brabo received some money of 8 fingers. In a sense he was the puppet in a position of power in the Kingdom. If he was not killed by Lupusregina there would be no need for Phillip to get up on the stage.