Talk:Adventurer's Guild/@comment-209.197.138.25-20150727234121/@comment-45.56.46.26-20180604104534

I don't think it's likely that she would have been the 9th seat, the 2nd seat gear seems to match her fighting style better (also, the current 2nd seat looks to be rather recently promoted). Also, they definitely talk about her before, and the attitude is quite divergent.

When they talk about the former 9th seat, they segue right into talking about other retired members of the Black Scripture, so I think that Windstride may be of particular interest for some other reason (possibly God-kin?) but is also normally retired rather than a traitor.

Zurrernorn is probably the most likely culprit behind Clementine and Khajit's disappearing act. They some other unresolved threads as well.