Talk:Rubedo/@comment-2A02:A442:4DB:1:FDE1:7E86:93BA:9312-20170803110201/@comment-28784974-20170825133830

Replying to your summarized comment.

That's not me failing to read your comment. That's you misunderstanding me.

" Saying that The Goal of All Life is Death wouldn't work on Rubedo is the same as saying any special skill wouldn't work on an NPC made of a WCI"

That's what I said. Now, did I say TGOALID would work on Rubedo? There is little to no evidence supporting the theory that it would work on her. However, you can't say it wouldn't work on her either despite being hints and vague evidence to support this claim. Until the author confirms it himslef in the LN or by directly stating it himself, we fans have no saying in this. That is my point.

1. I don't see anything worth discussing over, since I actually agree with you on this.

2. No, you didn't say it, that's just you missing my point, which was an example. I never said you stated such a thing. Also as for '''" I said that a special skill or spell that goes against the effect of a WCI wouldn't work(which a fact)". ''' No, that's not a fact.

"Effects of a world class item can be resisted in only two ways: (1) Owning another world class item. (2) Getting special classes." ~WI Page.

As for your comment regarding the special skill not affecting the Caloric Stone, that's again, assuming it's the case here, but I'll get back to that later.

3. " THIS was my speculation. Point 1 and 2 are facts"

Speculation wouldn't the right word to discribe your second point, I'd say headcanon is more fitting, and your third point is a speculation, as you said it yourself. The only thing I'd actually call fact is your first point.

For one, I like the theory of Rubedo being made of a WCI, and yes there are some evidence backing that theory up, and most fans agree with it. But that's really just it. Until the series/author confirms it, it will only remain a theory, and not a fact.